(DOWNLOAD) "Stoddard v. Public Utilities Commission" by Kennebec Supreme Court of Maine ~ eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: Stoddard v. Public Utilities Commission
- Author : Kennebec Supreme Court of Maine
- Release Date : January 15, 1941
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 63 KB
Description
The plaintiff brings this bill in equity to enjoin the enforcement of a rule of the Public Utilities Commission known as Regulation 1 K. The case is before us on report on bill, answer, replication and agreed statement. The plaintiff is a contract carrier who has been doing a trucking business in the state since 1929. In 1933 the legislature took the first step to bring this class of corporations under the control of the Public Utilities Commission. Public Laws 1933, Chap. 259. Under the provisions of Sec 5A of this act, all such carriers were required to obtain a permit to operate within the state. Section 5C, the so-called ""grandfather clause,"" provides that the permit shall ""be granted as a matter of right when it appears to the satisfaction of the commission, after hearing, that the applicant has been regularly engaged in the business of a contract carrier as herein defined within this state, from the first day of March, 1932, and in such cases, operation may lawfully be continued pending the issuance of such permit, provided application therefor is made within fifteen days from the effective date of this act."" The plaintiff, claiming to be entitled to a permit under this provision of the act, filed an application June 28, 1933. January 26, 1934, the Public Utilities Commission filed a decree certifying that he was a contract carrier and entitled to a permit ""covering the transportation of shipments between First National Stores located in Maine, and such other traffic wherein it is indicated that said National Stores is either the consignor or consignee, subject however to the rate provisions contained in Section 5, Paragraph D, Chapter 259, Public Laws of 1933."" A permit was issued in accordance with this decree as of December 30, 1933 ""authorizing said applicant to operate a motor vehicle or motor vehicles as a Contract Carrier within the general area and/or for the general purpose within which and for which said applicant has been regularly engaged in transporting freight or merchandise for hire over the highways of this state from March 1, 1932 to June 30, 1933, the effective date of said Chapter 259."" Neither an exception nor an appeal was taken to the order of the commission. Renewal permits were granted from year to year in slightly different form but carrying the same general provisions. In the permit issued February 26, 1940, and running to March 1, 1941, the limitation imposed on the plaintiff is set forth as follows: ""To transport commodities between First National Stores located in Maine; and to transport such other traffic between points in Maine where it is indicated that the First National Stores is either the consignor or consignee.""